Now Reading: When Couples Keep Secrets: How Much Privacy Is Too Much?

Loading
A couple sitting side by side with quiet tension, symbolizing emotional distance caused by unspoken truths.
June 2, 2025 / Mondy Dorsainvil

When Couples Keep Secrets: How Much Privacy Is Too Much?

svg1.5K

Exploring the Delicate Balance Between Independence and Openness

Let’s just say it—

Even the healthiest relationships have secrets.

Not necessarily the scandalous, soap-opera kind.

Sometimes it’s:

📱 Deleting a convo that felt flirty

🧾 Not mentioning that online splurge

💭 Keeping a worry to yourself because “I don’t want to bother them”

But here’s the real question:

When does privacy become secrecy—and when does secrecy start chipping away at trust?

Spoiler Alert: You’re Still Two People, Even in Love

Being in a relationship doesn’t mean you become one giant emotionally fused being.

You’re still individuals.

You’re allowed:

🧠 Thoughts that stay in your head

📓 Journals no one reads

💆‍♀️ Moments you keep just for yourself

“Privacy is healthy. It’s space to think, feel, and breathe without editing yourself for someone else.”

But when privacy becomes withholding, that’s where the line blurs.

So… What’s the Difference Between Privacy and Secrecy?

🔐 Privacy = Boundaries rooted in respect.

🙈 Secrecy = Hidden actions rooted in fear or avoidance.

Ask yourself:

✔️ Is this something I’d be okay sharing later?

✔️ Am I hiding this to protect me, or because it would hurt them?

✔️ Is this information, or intimacy, I’m keeping from my partner?

If it’s about protecting your peace—you’re likely honoring privacy.

If it’s about protecting yourself from consequences—you’re probably keeping a secret.

“It’s not about full transparency. It’s about emotional integrity.”

Why Secrets Start—and Why They’re So Tempting

Secrets usually don’t start with evil intentions.

They start with:

😬 Avoiding conflict

😓 Fear of disappointing your partner

🙄 Assuming it’s “not a big deal”

😵‍💫 Telling yourself “They wouldn’t understand”

But the thing is, secrets have energy.

Even tiny ones.

And that energy starts to shift the atmosphere.

A vibe. A subtle disconnection. A lack of safety.

And before you know it, intimacy becomes polite distance.

When Is “Too Much Privacy” a Problem?

If you notice:

🚫 You’re making decisions that affect both of you—but not telling them

🚫 You feel relieved they didn’t find out something

🚫 You start feeling like you have a “me life” and a “we life” that don’t overlap

Then it might be time to check in.

Not because you’re doing something wrong—but because you might be building a wall where a window should be.

How to Rebuild Trust Without Oversharing Everything

No, you don’t have to announce every passing thought or explain every Amazon order 😅

But you do need openness around these:

  • Finances that affect you both 💰
  • Friendships with potential emotional heat 🔥
  • Big decisions, dreams, doubts, fears 💭

Try this:

🗣️ “Is there anything you feel I don’t understand about your inner world?”

💬 “Are there things we’re not talking about that we should be?”

🔄 Create a “Weekly Honesty Hour” where no topic is off limits

Because vulnerability isn’t about sharing everything.

It’s about sharing what matters.

Trust Isn’t Built by Oversharing—It’s Built by Intention

You’re not required to bare your soul 24/7.

But if you’re in love, you’re building something sacred:

A space where truth feels safe.

A space where you can say,

“This is mine… but I want to let you in.”

So if you’re wondering whether something’s a “secret” or “just private”—ask yourself:

👉 Would sharing this build connection?

👉 Would hiding it build distance?

Because love thrives in light.

Not with spotlights. Just with a soft, steady glow of honesty.

0 People voted this article. 0 Upvotes - 0 Downvotes.

Mondy Dorsainvil

I'm a Licensed Master Social Worker (LMSW) with over 12 years of experience in helping individuals, couples, and families navigate the complexities of their lives. Specializing in communication, conflict resolution, intimacy issues, and parenting challenges, I offer evidence-based and culturally sensitive therapeutic interventions tailored to each client’s unique needs. My approach is systemic and strengths-based, focusing on leveraging inherent strengths to achieve personal and relational goals. Committed to professional development, I stay abreast of the latest research and practices in Marriage and Family Therapy, including LGBTQ+ affirmative therapy. Join me here as we explore insightful strategies for positive change and personal growth.

svg

What do you think?

It is nice to know your opinion. Leave a comment.

Leave a reply

Loading
svg

Quick Navigation

  • 1

    When Couples Keep Secrets: How Much Privacy Is Too Much?